Free writing critiques: my way of giving back
When I was first beginning to write, I thought each and every word was solid gold, assuring me I was one step closer to a Pulitzer Prize. These days, I realize I’m about average for a published author, but even so, I have something to offer those who are just starting to write.
As a new writer, I remember how important it was to have others read and enjoy what I’d written. I soon found online writing critique groups, where my sample chapter or short story was posted for all to see and crit, while I sat back and cringed, waiting for the inevitable (bad) news. I have something slightly different to offer.
If you are a new, unpublished writer, unsure whether your writing is ready for prime time, and you’re simply looking for some validation, please feel free to post a paragraph or two of your writing as a comment on this blog post. I will keep it hidden unless you state otherwise, and I will offer you some feedback in the form of a ranking– sort of a beginner, intermediate, expert ranking. I will not go into a tremendous amount of detail, but just let you know where I think you stand.
A beginner might be someone who has recently begun writing, and perhaps would benefit from joining an online writing group or attending some workshops. This does not mean you should give up writing. It simply means you will improve over time.
Intermediate might be someone who has a moderate amount of talent which shows through in their writing, but still needs to work on their technique.
An expert would be someone who was born to write. They are ready to be published! (Sadly, at first, I fell into the “beginner” ranking).
Note: if the writing does not appeal to me in any way, (ie too violent, too graphic, etc.), I will not give a ranking or publish the comment on my blog.
My opinions are simply that– OPINIONS. Generally, I won’t be able to give a full critique. This will be only for beginning, unpublished writers who would like a little feedback. Just my way of giving back to the ever-growing writing community.




